At Point Park University, coach Mark Jackson used a wide range of categories—like leadership, dedication, and concern for teammates—to evaluate his players. In 1999, despite returning an experienced team fresh off a College World Series appearance, Jackson was stunned by the results of a freshman, Don Kelly, who scored the highest on the team in those evaluations.
“Freshmen usually need time to adjust,” Jackson said. “But Donnie was different. He came in and immediately earned the team’s respect. I knew back then he was special, and he proved it over the next three years.”
Now 45, Kelly has been named the new manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates, replacing Derek Shelton after the team’s rough 12-26 start. Kelly played under Jackson from 1999 to 2001 before being drafted by the Detroit Tigers. He’s served as the Pirates’ bench coach since 2019 and, despite interest from other MLB teams, this marks his first role as a full-time manager.
Jackson, who coached at Point Park in two stints and led the team to five College World Series appearances, still keeps in touch with Kelly. He remembers him as a standout both on and off the field—an NAIA All-American who hit .413 and later played nine years in MLB.
“He combines passion with compassion,” Jackson said. “He genuinely cares about people and listens with full attention. He has a rare quality that makes others feel valued.”
Al Liberi, Kelly’s former hitting coach in high school and later at Point Park, also spoke highly of Kelly’s character and work ethic. “Even in high school, he was humble,” Liberi said. “He’s got incredible baseball knowledge and a deep love for the game.”
Joe Oliphant, Kelly’s former college roommate and longtime friend, described him as “selfless” and committed to helping others succeed. “He’s always been about making people better,” Oliphant said. “No one has anything bad to say about him.”
Pirates GM Ben Cherington confirmed that Kelly’s title is not “interim manager,” though he didn’t make long-term commitments beyond 2025. Still, he echoed praise from those who know Kelly well.
“He’s a natural teacher,” Cherington said. “While things might not change overnight, I believe his approach will have a real, lasting impact on the team.”
Although taking over a struggling team is a big challenge, many believe Kelly is exactly the kind of leader the Pirates need.
“He’s one of the best people I’ve ever met,” Jackson said. “It doesn’t surprise me at all that he’s now managing the Pirates. He’s caring, sincere, and truly special. He leaves a lasting impression on everyone he meets.”
